Aespa

[Guest]

Karina said no to marriage

[spoiler]

[/spoiler]

There is more
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]


Except if you're pretty then she'll propose to you
[spoiler]
[/spoiler]

[Guest]

Now I wonder if those asking for marriage were dudes or girls

Tbh I find these fans so cringy but at the same time I'm like well, congrats for having the courage to be so damn bold I can't relate.

[Guest]

Now I wonder if those asking for marriage were dudes or girls

Tbh I find these fans so cringy but at the same time I'm like well, congrats for having the courage to be so damn bold I can't relate.

Aespa keeps RV tradition, I think the most of the fandom are women

When aespa attended mama (i think?) and there were fans, they took a picture and Karina put it as bble background and I can only see lots of women
[spoiler][/spoiler]

[Guest]

Now I wonder if those asking for marriage were dudes or girls

Tbh I find these fans so cringy but at the same time I'm like well, congrats for having the courage to be so damn bold I can't relate.

Aespa keeps RV tradition, I think the most of the fandom are women

When aespa attended mama (i think?) and there were fans, they took a picture and Karina put it as bble background and I can only see lots of women
[spoiler][/spoiler]

Mama audience is for all groups attending and nearly all were boy groups so it would be mostly women? Or am I wrong.

[Guest]

Now I wonder if those asking for marriage were dudes or girls

Tbh I find these fans so cringy but at the same time I'm like well, congrats for having the courage to be so damn bold I can't relate.

Aespa keeps RV tradition, I think the most of the fandom are women

When aespa attended mama (i think?) and there were fans, they took a picture and Karina put it as bble background and I can only see lots of women
[spoiler][/spoiler]

Mama audience is for all groups attending and nearly all were boy groups so it would be mostly women? Or am I wrong.

This year for covid was different, it was pre-recorded and limited to amount of fans per group

[Guest]

Now I wonder if those asking for marriage were dudes or girls

Tbh I find these fans so cringy but at the same time I'm like well, congrats for having the courage to be so damn bold I can't relate.

Aespa keeps RV tradition, I think the most of the fandom are women

When aespa attended mama (i think?) and there were fans, they took a picture and Karina put it as bble background and I can only see lots of women
[spoiler][/spoiler]

Mama audience is for all groups attending and nearly all were boy groups so it would be mostly women? Or am I wrong.

[Guest]

The way Karina went all out for Winter's birthday, spamming pic after pic after pic. You can tell she really has a soft spot for her

the way she waited around 12mn to post her greeting she even told the next day she fell asleep doing so

[Guest]

Honestly, i never thought that it will be Karina who will be on our sus list, and I also never thought that she's be this flirty with women and be an extrovert. I really thought it would be Winter lol

[Guest]

NingNing casually scheduling a date with a female fan lmao

[Guest]

Honestly, i never thought that it will be Karina who will be on our sus list, and I also never thought that she's be this flirty with women and be an extrovert. I really thought it would be Winter lol

From what I saw, winter seems the shyiest of the group

From less to more shy:
Ningning (she does her own thing and mind her own business) > Karina > Giselle > Winter

But once giselle is comfortable, I can imagine she is the wildest (off camera) along with Ningning while Karina and Winter are more well mannered

[Guest]

Honestly, i never thought that it will be Karina who will be on our sus list, and I also never thought that she's be this flirty with women and be an extrovert. I really thought it would be Winter lol

From what I saw, winter seems the shyiest of the group

From less to more shy:
Ningning (she does her own thing and mind her own business) > Karina > Giselle > Winter

But once giselle is comfortable, I can imagine she is the wildest (off camera) along with Ningning while Karina and Winter are more well mannered

Da

Yeah, i think NingNing and Giselle are the type to socialize more. If they werent idols and were ordinary college student, i bet you'll see them at every college party lol

As for Karina, she's the type who will initiate if she likes you, just like how she would ask her pretty classmates out, how she asked Yeji out and how she approached Winter when they first met each other as trainees.

As for Winter, awkward around new people but will loosen up once you spend more time together

[Guest]

NingNing casually scheduling a date with a female fan lmao

I love how open-minded NingNing is. Isnt she the one who posted SolJiwan on bubble? Since she's roomates with Karina i guess it is safe to say they watched Nevertheless together

[Guest]

Honestly, i never thought that it will be Karina who will be on our sus list, and I also never thought that she's be this flirty with women and be an extrovert. I really thought it would be Winter lol

From what I saw, winter seems the shyiest of the group

From less to more shy:
Ningning (she does her own thing and mind her own business) > Karina > Giselle > Winter

But once giselle is comfortable, I can imagine she is the wildest (off camera) along with Ningning while Karina and Winter are more well mannered

Da

Yeah, i think NingNing and Giselle are the type to socialize more. If they werent idols and were ordinary college student, i bet you'll see them at every college party lol

As for Karina, she's the type who will initiate if she likes you, just like how she would ask her pretty classmates out, how she asked Yeji out and how she approached Winter when they first met each other as trainees.

As for Winter, awkward around new people but will loosen up once you spend more time together

Ningning is the social butterfly of the group, all the idols she's friend with and nobody knew (and the ones who don't know yet). I mean they went to NYC and Ningning hanged out with two different group friends How Ningning has friends in nyc too??

[Guest]

NingNing casually scheduling a date with a female fan lmao

I love how open-minded NingNing is. Isnt she the one who posted SolJiwan on bubble? Since she's roomates with Karina i guess it is safe to say they watched Nevertheless together

I think all of them watched nevertheless together, Giselle mentioned the show too and Karina posted the ost of the show on bble. I'm waiting for Ningning femenist scandal, she loves the book pride and prejudice because it told us women should be think independiently

[spoiler]



The black text is what she wrote on bble
[/spoiler]

[Guest]

NingNing watches Euphoria i wonder what she thinks of Jules' and Rue's scenes? They are pretty explicit arent they?

[guest]

NingNing watches Euphoria i wonder what she thinks of Jules' and Rue's scenes? They are pretty explicit arent they?

isn't the Jule character is a man

[Guest]

Good for her, our NingNing

[Guest]

I still have Ningning on the watchlist, either ally or one of us. At least we can say she's an ally for sure, the two screenshots of shows were from lgbt couples (i'm not gonna got into trans discussion) so she's knows what she's doing

[Guest]

I still have Ningning on the watchlist, either ally or one of us. At least we can say she's an ally for sure, the two screenshots of shows were from lgbt couples (i'm not gonna got into trans discussion) so she's knows what she's doing

*(i'm not gonna get into trans discussion) she knows

[Guest]

NingNing watches Euphoria i wonder what she thinks of Jules' and Rue's scenes? They are pretty explicit arent they?

isn't the Jule character is a man

Da

She's trans actually. I think it just shows that NingNing is open minded since she consumes gay content (Nevertheless, Euphoria, loves Frank Ocean etc.)

Doesnt really have to mean anything. It is just nice to see a kpop idol openly watching shows with LGBT storyline, no matter what it is

[guest]

NingNing watches Euphoria i wonder what she thinks of Jules' and Rue's scenes? They are pretty explicit arent they?

isn't the Jule character is a man

Da

She's trans actually. I think it just shows that NingNing is open minded since she consumes gay content (Nevertheless, Euphoria, loves Frank Ocean etc.)

Doesnt really have to mean anything. It is just nice to see a kpop idol openly watching shows with LGBT storyline, no matter what it is

he is he not she XY science go back to school kid

[Guest]

Agree or disagree if that person is a he or she, let's not discuss it here, this is not the thread for that. Just focus on the important info about Ningning

[Guest]

Good for her, our NingNing

that tweet is disgusting though..."fruity"? Why do straight people do this whyyyy

[guest]

Agree or disagree if that person is a he or she, let's not discuss it here, this is not the thread for that. Just focus on the important info about Ningning

then stop talking about men. I was enjoying the aespa thread but you have to ruin it with men talk

[Guest]

NingNing watches Euphoria i wonder what she thinks of Jules' and Rue's scenes? They are pretty explicit arent they?

isn't the Jule character is a man

Da

She's trans actually. I think it just shows that NingNing is open minded since she consumes gay content (Nevertheless, Euphoria, loves Frank Ocean etc.)

Doesnt really have to mean anything. It is just nice to see a kpop idol openly watching shows with LGBT storyline, no matter what it is

he is he not she XY science go back to school kid

Da

No one is debating you on that? the anon just said that NingNing is open minded since she watches shows with LGBT content.

This isnt the place for trans discussion anyway, the only take away here is that NingNing is at least a great ally

[Guest]

Move on, please.

[Guest]

This isnt the place for trans discussion anyway, the only take away here is that NingNing is at least a great ally

Exactly this isn't the place for that and the only thing people have to take from this is Ningning is an ally (at least) so move on from any trans discussion

[Guest]

The op is so lucky being able to hold Karina's hand

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Not, not really. People always jokes about aespa being one the straightest groups out there Karina would be seen as straight (the most still think that tho) if it wasn't for her love women

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Nope.

[Guest]

This is OP, I made this thread to peacefully discuss about Aespa without trolls shutting down everything.
If you want to debate about whether Jules is a man or not go to the K-ent thread, it's been a shitshow for a while now anyway.

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Tbh she doesnt, she just seems like a really really cool gal.

However, if she does end up with a gf one day, it wont surprise me either. She seems like the type who will go for what she likes

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

No, she's probably supportive and an ally but she's most likely straight.

[Guest]

This is OP, I made this thread to peacefully discuss about Aespa without trolls shutting down everything.
If you want to debate about whether Jules is a man or not go to the K-ent thread, it's been a shitshow for a while now anyway.

Mate, we literally just moved on and we didnt even dig into that topic here as we shut it down immediately. No need to remind us

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Tbh she doesnt, she just seems like a really really cool gal.

However, if she does end up with a gf one day, it wont surprise me either. She seems like the type who will go for what she likes

Same thoughts about her, i think she's a very open minded person and she's an ally. I'll wait for more content if she moves from the ally status to lgbt one tho

[guest8]

This is OP, I made this thread to peacefully discuss about Aespa without trolls shutting down everything.
If you want to debate about whether Jules is a man or not go to the K-ent thread, it's been a shitshow for a while now anyway.

you should learn the lesson and never bring men here especially the ones who think they are women.

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Tbh she doesnt, she just seems like a really really cool gal.

However, if she does end up with a gf one day, it wont surprise me either. She seems like the type who will go for what she likes

X2

It is just lovely to know that she's such a cool person.

Now let me ask this, does Winter ping to you?

[Guest]

I think Winter only pings to people because she a liiiiiiiiiittle bit tomboyish when you compare her with the other 3. Which is a bit absurd...

As far as I know, she has not done anything or said anything that could be sus.

[Guest]

Does NingNing ping for any of you?

Tbh she doesnt, she just seems like a really really cool gal.

However, if she does end up with a gf one day, it wont surprise me either. She seems like the type who will go for what she likes

X2

It is just lovely to know that she's such a cool person.

Now let me ask this, does Winter ping to you?

Nah she doesnt. I know the fandom loves Winrina and i admit they are cute together, probably one of the ships with real chemistry, but Winter seems straight to me tbh

[Guest]

I think Winter only pings to people because she a liiiiiiiiiittle bit tomboyish when you compare her with the other 3. Which is a bit absurd...

As far as I know, she has not done anything or said anything that could be sus.

Winter is like Seulgi, she pings to those who thinks tomboyish = lesbian. And to those who take shipping too seriously (although i think Karina does have a slight crush)

[Guest]

I think Winter only pings to people because she a liiiiiiiiiittle bit tomboyish when you compare her with the other 3. Which is a bit absurd...

As far as I know, she has not done anything or said anything that could be sus.

Winter is like Seulgi, she pings to those who thinks tomboyish = lesbian. And to those who take shipping too seriously (although i think Karina does have a slight crush)

If there is an attraction between the two of them, it's probably on Karina's side only but won't act on it since they're best friends. As much as I want to ship them (since they really look good together), I just feel like there's no chance between them

[Guest]

I think Winter only pings to people because she a liiiiiiiiiittle bit tomboyish when you compare her with the other 3. Which is a bit absurd...

As far as I know, she has not done anything or said anything that could be sus.

da the anon who compared her to Seulgi is spot on. I won't be shocked if SM pushes a Winrina subunit in the future.

[Guest]

I think Winter only pings to people because she a liiiiiiiiiittle bit tomboyish when you compare her with the other 3. Which is a bit absurd...

As far as I know, she has not done anything or said anything that could be sus.

da the anon who compared her to Seulgi is spot on. I won't be shocked if SM pushes a Winrina subunit in the future.

Da

SM does have that habit of capitalizing on a group's famous ship. They did it with Taeny, Kryber, and Seulrene. They will definitely do it with Winrina too in the future, and it also helps that they are the most famous members

[Guest]

[Guest]

As much as I love seeing them perform I dread having to listen to that god-awful song again

[Guest]

[spoiler][/spoiler]

As much as I love seeing them perform I dread having to listen to that god-awful song again

The best thing about this song was the perfomance so I'm glad we're getting a perfomance at least since we don't have a dance practice or anything And it's always nice seeing them together again

[Guest]

Well, we can always mute the video

[Guest]

I too hate the song & it's lyrics are horrible but I'm just glad to see them performing on stage again.
I just hope they don't feel too overworked with them just finishing Dreams Come True promo & allegedly preparing for a comeback.

[Guest]

I too hate the song & it's lyrics are horrible but I'm just glad to see them performing on stage again.
I just hope they don't feel too overworked with them just finishing Dreams Come True promo & allegedly preparing for a comeback.

It will be fine, it's just one perfomance and this is the least overworked they will be once covid is gone